Man In Dilemma - Should He Evict Sick Niece From Wife's Side So His Screwup Nephew Could Move In

"I told Anne we'll give her some time to find another place"

Damjan

• Published in Interesting
• October 20, 2023

Dealing with family stuff can get pretty tricky, especially when it comes to where people live and how they manage money. In this story, OP is in the middle of a big family situation. OP's nephew, Sam, and niece, Anne, are the main characters in this family drama.

Sam is the son of OP's brother, and Anne is the daughter of OP's wife's sister. Anne used to go to college and lived in a special place for students. But now, she's taken a break from college, and it's not sure if she'll go back or how long her break will last.

OP owns an apartment in the area where they all live. Anne and her mom asked if Anne could stay there for a while because she couldn't stay in the student place anymore. OP said yes, and Anne doesn't have to pay rent. Sometimes, she helps with the bills.

Now, things have gotten a bit complicated. Sam, OP's nephew lost his job but found another one that doesn't pay much. He and his partner are having a tough time paying for a place to live.

OP and their spouse talked about what to do. OP thinks Anne should find another place to live eventually, and Sam and his partner can move in. But not everyone in the family agrees.

Anne and her mom don't want to share the apartment with people they don't know. OP's spouse is on their side.

All of this has led to arguments and tensions in the family, with Anne upset about having to move out, and OP's spouse saying it's not fair. So, OP has to figure out how to make things right for everyone.

Anne is the daughter of OP's wife's sister, and she has been living in OP's apartment for a few months. OP doesn't ask her to pay rent, but she sometimes helps with the utility bills.

The problem arises when OP's nephew loses his job, prompting OP to offer his apartment to him, leading to Ann needing to move out.

OP should update his post with clarifications

Anne should be allowed to stay, especially if she needs medical care nearby.

OP is in the wrong for favoring his spendthrift nephew and his wife over his niece who needs a place to stay during her leave.

Your post is deceptive

OP had a commitment with Anne, and it's wrong to break it for someone older who can't manage money.

OP should have provided all relevant information upfront instead of revealing it in later comments.

OP allowed his niece to stay without rent or conditions, but now he is unfairly evicting her just to accommodate someone else.

OP shows favoritism towards his cousin.

OP is wrong because Anne is still sick, and his nephew needs to budget better.

Easy life vs. disease

OP didn't initially include all the pertinent information in the post; the comments have shed light on many crucial details. It's crucial to take into account the circumstances and priorities in this situation.

Anne had to temporarily halt her studies due to serious health issues, and her offer to pay rent demonstrates her determination to resume her education.

Conversely, Sam and his partner's insistence on upholding a lavish lifestyle despite financial difficulties raises ethical concerns. It's imperative to carefully consider compassion and fairness in this scenario, giving precedence to Anne's well-being and health over extravagance.

Damjan