Unveiling The Dark Side Of Cheerful Pictures

A quick heads-up: some of these stories might be a bit much for certain readers.

Damjan

• Published in Weird
• November 16, 2024

There are pictures around that document happy, loving, and joyful occasions. We frequently assume we know exactly what's happening when we look at them. However, often, an innocent, joyful image conceals something considerably deeper.

This demonstrates how crucial context is when examining photographs; just as we shouldn't judge a book by its cover, we shouldn't evaluate a photo by its appearance. We typically see cheerful faces, smiles, or stunning landscapes when we look at pictures.

However, occasionally, a disturbing backstory hides beneath those grins. A seemingly serene portrait may contain a tragic, sorrowful, or even dangerous past. This serves as a reminder that images sometimes convey only some of the picture.

On r/AskReddit, a Reddit user going by the handle KermitTheFraud92 launched a conversation inviting users to post images with unsettling backstories. Many people joined in, posting pictures with a much deeper significance when you know the backstory.

At first glance, these images may appear innocuous, but upon closer inspection, they reveal how much can be concealed in a single image. A picture of a family enjoying themselves at the beach serves as one illustration.

When you read the narrative, you find it was taken on the same day the family suffered a tragedy, even though it appears to be a picture of the ideal family moment. In reality, the joyful expressions in the photo concealed suffering and sorrow. This demonstrates how images may be deceptive—something that appears joyful on the surface could hide something unpleasant.

Proceed with caution.

"Camp Staff Taking A Day Off"

The images of Auschwitz staff on their days off. They seem like camp counselors, but their role was to kill people in unimaginable ways, and they seemed to take pleasure in it. Many of them likely took lives just before or after these photos were snapped.

"Jewish Children Holding Hands As They Unknowingly Walk To Their Deaths In The Gas Chambers At Auschwitz"

"This Photo May Not Look Like Much At First"

Look at the figure in the top left corner and notice the background on the right. That's the Tank Man from the Tiananmen Square massacre.

Often believed to be student Wang Weilin, this photo was taken just moments before the iconic image was captured. What happened to Weilin remains unknown.

He could have been executed, might still be in prison, or perhaps he escaped to another country.

"This Photo Always Gets To Me Somehow"

A group of astronauts floats in zero gravity, enjoying the unique privilege of life in space, as astronauts often do. They’re all smiles, unaware that their shuttle is fatally compromised. In just a few days, what should have been a routine reentry will end in disaster.

This is the crew of the Space Shuttle Columbia. The damage happened during launch when a piece of foam struck the shuttle’s heat-resistant tiles. At the time, no one grasped how severe it was—until the shuttle broke apart.

"This Is A Pic Of The 1970's-Era Gameshow, The Dating Game"

The man in the circle is Rodney Alcala, a serial killer. By the time he appeared on the show, he had already raped several women and killed at least one.

He won the game, but the woman never went out with him. It’s easy to see why she probably felt a tremendous sense of relief.

"Father And Daughter In Omagh, Northern Ireland"

This photo, showing a father and daughter sharing a moment of happiness, was taken just moments before the Omagh car bombing in 1998. The bomb, planted by the Real IRA, was hidden in the red car and claimed the lives of 29 people, including the photographer. Both the father and daughter were among the survivors.

"This Photo Creeps Me Out"

John Lennon signed an autograph for Mark Chapman, his future killer, just hours before the shooting. At the time, Chapman even had a gun with him, and Lennon casually asked, "Is that all?"

"The Hartley Violin"

The Hartley Violin once belonged to Wallace Hartley, the bandmaster and lead violinist aboard the Titanic. It’s the same violin he carried and played during the ship’s final moments.

Survivors recall seeing Hartley and his band on the deck, playing music to calm passengers as they boarded the lifeboats. All of the band members perished in the sinking, but Hartley had managed to secure the violin in its monogrammed case before he died.

It was later found floating among the wreckage by a recovery team, identified by a brass plate engraved with his name. The violin was returned to Hartley’s fiancée, who kept it until her death. The family later authenticated the instrument and sold it for $1.6M to a Titanic artifact collector.

"Genie Standing For A Photo"

Genie had a troubled childhood. She spent most of her early years tied to a chair in a room, punished whenever she made any noise.

When she was eventually discovered and rescued, efforts were made to teach her to speak. Though she never fully acquired language, she did manage to communicate to some extent.

She was curious, intelligent, and eager to learn, but the critical period for language development had already passed. As far as we know, she has been living in an assisted care facility ever since.

"American Physicist Harold Agnew"

This is physicist Harold Agnew holding the nuclear core of the Fat Man atomic bomb, dropped on Nagasaki in 1945.

The bomb claimed around 80,000 lives, with many more suffering from long-term effects like radiation sickness and leukemia.

"Franklin Delano Floyd And Suzanne Marie Sevakis"

The image at the forefront is of Franklin Delano Floyd, but the young girl in the photo is his stepdaughter, Suzanne Marie Sevakis. Floyd had kidnapped Suzanne in 1974 when she was still a child, under 10 years old.

He kept her hidden, raising her as his daughter and enrolling her in high school under various false identities. In 1988, Suzanne had a son with Floyd, and the following year, they married under the alias Tonya Hughes.

By 1990, Suzanne had made plans to escape Floyd’s control and take her son, Michael, with her. In April of that year, she was found severely beaten on the side of a highway and later died in the hospital. Michael was placed in foster care and later adopted, only to be taken by Floyd in 1994. After that, he disappeared without a trace.

"If You're British, And Of A Certain Age, You'll Probably Be As Haunted By This Grainy Image As I Am"

"I still distinctly remember the first time I saw it. At the time, James Bulger was only missing, and it was regarded as a cause for optimism that he was last seen with other children. The truth was far worse than anyone imagined, and still inspires a visceral reaction unlike any other crime in my lifetime."

"American Volcanologist David A. Johnston"

Thirteen hours after the photo was taken, Mount St. Helens erupted on May 18, 1980, claiming the lives of 57 people, including the volcanologist.

"This Photo Of Howard Ashman And Alan Menken, Who Wrote The Lyrics And Music Respectively For The Little Mermaid, Beauty And The Beast And Aladdin. In This Photo They Had Just Won Oscars For The Little Mermaid"

That night, Ashman told Menken they needed to talk seriously when returning to New York. A few days later, Ashman shared that he had AIDS and was going to die.

They had been songwriting partners for more than a decade and were in the middle of working on Beauty and the Beast. The photo may look joyful between two men reaching their biggest dream, but it's the last time they shared a "normal" moment. While Menken is all smiles, Ashman’s expression reveals something’s off.

"John Edward Robinson And His Family"

This is John Edward Robinson, a convicted serial killer, wearing a yellow sweater and holding baby Tiffany Stasi, whose mother he killed just one day before. Robinson told his brother that Tiffany was adopted, a story that would remain undisclosed for 15 years. Only eight of his victims have been identified, and he’s been on death row since 2000.

"The Final Picture Of The Webster Sisters And Their Friend"

They’re all smiling, looking carefree in their selfie, but then you spot the bright light behind them and can’t help but feel like they’re about to get hit by a train.

"Uruguayan Air Force Flight 571"

This photo shows a group of survivors from the Uruguayan Air Force Flight 571 crash in the Andes. After days of struggle, they were rescued, but not without having to make the harrowing decision to resort to cannibalism. While they smile in the image, the human spine on the right side adds a chilling detail to the scene.

"Polish Constitution Day Celebration In Chicago"

This 1978 photo shows First Lady Rosalynn Carter shaking hands with John Wayne Gacy, who was already a convicted serial killer by this time, with over 20 young men dead. At the time, Gacy was involved in local politics.

He’s wearing an "S" pin, which the Secret Service issued to indicate his security clearance. Carter also signed the image with a message, "To John Gacy, best wishes, Rosalynn Carter."

"JP Morgan And Lya Graf"

This photo of JP Morgan with Lya Graf, a performer from the Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus, thrust her into the spotlight, but the sudden fame was too much for her. She returned to Germany, only to face the horrors of Nazi persecution.

As a Jewish woman deemed "unfit," she was arrested and sent to Auschwitz. Details about her fate are scarce, but it’s believed that neither she nor her family survived.

"Two Trails In The Snow. Only One Is Leading Back To Life"

This photo was taken by Kurt Diemberger after his climbing partner, the renowned alpinist Hermann Buhl, fell into the abyss on Chogolisa in the Himalayas. Buhl had been following Diemberger but briefly veered off the trail, only to fall through an overhanging cornice, where he remains frozen in the ice.

"A Still Photo From A Video"

A man swam to his girlfriend in their underwater hotel room during a vacation in Tanzania, proposing with a note and a ring. Tragically, he didn’t make it back to the surface.

"La Mataviejitas, Juana Barraza"

Juana Barraza, once a Luchadora, went on to become a notorious serial killer. Sold to a man by her mother at just 12 in exchange for three beers, she was later found by her stepfather at 17.

With four failed marriages and four children, she lived a tough life doing cleaning jobs. Her crimes involved strangling older women who reminded her of her mother, often posing as a government worker to gain their trust.

"Photo Of Serial Killer Christopher Wilder Lurking In The Background During A Seventeen Magazine Fashion Show At The Meadows Mall In Las Vegas On April 1, 1984"

Wilder kidnaped and killed 17-year-old Michelle Kaufman, whom he met at a fashion show, where she stood in the foreground.

"Missing Big Island Hiker"

A child went missing while hiking on the Big Island of Hawaii. He had sent a few pictures of the scenery during his hike, but when he didn’t return home, his family noticed something unsettling in the photos—a figure lurking in the bushes. According to his relatives in Hawaii, the trail he was on is off-limits, so it’s unlikely it was a busy spot with many hikers around.

"Tyler Hadley's Florida House Party"

This photo shows Tyler Hadley holding a cup at a party at his house. Just hours earlier, he had murdered his parents with a hammer and hidden their bodies in the master bedroom.

During the party, Tyler took his best friend, Michael Mandell, to the room where the crime happened. Michael snapped this photo, unsure when he’d see Tyler again.

"In The "Old Days" It Used To Be Common To Take Pictures With Dead Relatives. The Woman In The Middle Is Already Dead"

"Two Guys Going For A Coffe At A Gas Station"

Salah Abdeslam and his driver were heading back to Belgium just a day after he orchestrated the 2015 Paris attack that claimed 131 lives.

"The Menendez Brothers Appeared In The Background Of A Basketball Card With The Photo For The Card Being Taken After They Had Killed Their Parents"

"This Photo Of Travis Alexander By Jodi Arias... Moments Before She Killed Him. It's Haunting To Me"

"The Whitakers At A Graduation Dinner"

Bart Whitaker, the young man on the right, hired two friends to murder his family that night. His mother and brother were killed, but his father, who took the photo, survived.

Bart was initially sentenced to death, but after his father spoke out against the decision, Texas Governor Greg Abbott intervened, granting clemency. He is now serving a life sentence.

Occasionally, people purposefully make their images appear happy when concealing something darker. A picture of pals enjoying a good time can conceal something more severe. Some photographs are shot to divert attention from what's actually happening behind the scenes, particularly those related to crime or danger.

This also calls into question how we perceive people in pictures—people who appear joyful and kind to us are frequently considered decent and ordinary.

However, some of the most vicious or dangerous persons might appear identical. In pictures, they may laugh and smile while concealing their genuine motivations. For this reason, we shouldn't always believe what we see in photos. A picture only captures a single point in time; it doesn't necessarily tell the entire tale.

Damjan