Frustrated Teen Tosses Out Makeup Palette In Attempt To Clean Up Mess Her Sister Made, Regrets Decision Later

"I’m also upset that mom is completely ignoring the fact the my sister lied"

Damjan

• Published in Interesting
• July 15, 2023

The relationship between teenage sisters is far from a flawless tale of unity and friendship. Like any relationship, it encounters its fair share of challenges and conflicts.

Sibling rivalry and competition often come into play as sisters vie for attention, validation, and superiority in various aspects of their lives. Trivial disputes, invasion of personal space, and a desire to establish individuality within shared experiences are not uncommon occurrences.

Jealousy, resentment, and misunderstandings can strain the once unbreakable bond between sisters. In the case of OP (17) and her younger sister (15), a recurring situation arises where the more youthful sibling consistently evades responsibility for her messes.

Unfortunately, their parents frequently side with the sister's denial, leaving OP to bear the burden of cleaning up after her. This pattern persists, creating frustration and resentment within OP.

One day, when the sister carelessly left her makeup palette on the living room table, OP correctly identified it as belonging to her sibling. However, their mother unexpectedly took the sister's side and demanded that OP be the one to clean it up.

Feeling exasperated, OP decided to dispose of the palette, assuming nobody wanted to use an unidentified makeup item in the household. To her surprise, the sister panicked and retrieved the discarded palette, claiming it to be a gift from a close friend.

In response to this revelation, OP's mother criticized her actions and insisted on an apology and replacing the palette. In this predicament, OP hesitates, feeling that her sister's initial dishonesty is being overlooked and that apologizing would only encourage further blame-shifting.

Seeking external perspectives, OP turns to others to determine if her actions are wrong.

OP's sister consistently denies responsibility for messes, leading her parents to believe her and assign clean-up duties to OP.

OP throws away the make-up, because the sister denied that it was hers, considering that the owner did not call, OP throws it away

OP's mom accuses her of cruelty for throwing away her sister's makeup palette

It was a clever tactic to expose OP's sister's lie.

OP's sister and parents are the ones in the wrong. It was not cruel to throw away the item when everyone denied ownership

OP has no obligation to apologize or replace her sister's makeup

OP's sister's denial and OP's knowledge of it not being hers make it reasonable to treat it as trash

The sister is lazy and dishonest, but the mother's behavior is worse

OP's decision to throw away something you didn't want was completely reasonable

Implementing this strategy consistently, it may create a stronger incentive for the sister to take responsibility for her own messes.

OP's mom is disregarding the fact that her sister lied to avoid cleaning up

The mother tried to manipulate OP into taking care of the makeup palette, despite knowing it belonged to the sister

The makeup-throwing tactic employed by OP proved effective in demonstrating that she was not responsible for the mess. The incident highlighted the sister's pattern of denying ownership and shifting blame, reinforcing the need for her to take responsibility for her actions.

However, the response from their parents fell short of expectations. Rather than supporting OP, they made an unreasonable demand for an apology. This reaction failed to acknowledge the sister's dishonesty and sent the message that it was acceptable to attribute blame to OP unfairly.

Given the circumstances, it is clear that OP's actions were justified, and the request for an apology was unwarranted.

Damjan