Family Quarrel Over Ice Cream Opens Debate On Sharing Food

"So we agreed that it's fair, each person gets 5."

Damjan

• Published in Interesting
• January 11, 2024

In every family, there's a familiar struggle over sharing treats fairly. It's a tale as old as time, where each person vies for their fair share, and sometimes, things don't go as planned.

This story, unfolding in a household of three, spotlights the classic domestic challenge: the equitable division of ice cream. Our protagonist, OP of this story, lives with her mom and younger sister.

In their home, a box of 15 ice creams became the center of a familial controversy. The agreement was simple: each person would enjoy five ice creams.

A fair deal, one might say. But the plot thickens when OP discovers a breach of this agreement.

Upon inspecting the freezer, a mere two ice creams remained. OP, having only indulged in two thus far, rightfully claimed these as theirs. The younger sister, already surpassing her allotment, eyed the frozen treats with desire. An argument ensued.

OP stood her ground, pointing out the unfairness of the situation. Yet, in a twist of events, the sister consumed the ice cream, leading to accusations of selfishness thrown at our protagonist.

Is it selfish to expect fairness in treatment distribution? Or is it greedy to consume more than one's share? OP, feeling wronged and outnumbered, grapples with these questions.

OP's family purchased a box of 15 ice creams, allowing each person to have 5.

A conflict arose when OP's sister wanted the last two, but OP claimed them as hers due to a prior fair agreement.

Now she is being criticized for being selfish and monitoring food consumption.

OP's mom and sister are not fair.

OP's mom should teach OP's sister about boundaries and eating habits.

OP can mark her food, so she can eat it at her own pace without worry.

She should simply check with OP first.

The question raised is why to have an agreed-upon portion per person if stealing is allowed.

OP's mom's behavior is unfair and appears to favor OP's sister, which may lead to entitlement issues for her.

OP should simply purchase additional ice cream.

It's unfair that OP's family agreed to a plan but didn't follow through.

OP is not the bad guy in this situation.

OP is not at fault for claiming her food.

To solve this, OP should use a zip-lock bag, place her share in it, and label it with her name.

OP is not wrong, but the situation is frustrating.

What happened with the ice cream isn't fair. OP's mom should teach OP's sister about sharing and not taking things without asking.

To solve this, OP can put her name on her food so she can eat it when she wants. Her sister should ask before taking it.

It's confusing why they agreed to share equally but didn't do it. If this keeps happening, it might make OP's sister feel like she can do whatever she wants.

In the end, it's important to be fair and stick to agreements in a family.

Damjan