Family Drama Erupts As Parent Decides To Sell Second Home, Leaving Daughter Homeless After Two Years Of Rent-Free Living

Apparently, the daughter made some major upgrades, thereby increasing the value of the house. So, how do they settle this?

Jesse

• Published in Interesting
• June 12, 2024

Inheriting a home from a beloved parent who has passed on can be both a blessing and a bittersweet reminder of their absence. Our narrator (Original Poster) found themselves in this very situation, having inherited a house from their mother years ago. 

Though it was far from the latest modern design, it was still in good condition. This same house soon became a lifeline for their daughter and her husband, who had fallen on hard times.

Two years ago, OP welcomed the couple into their house rent-free to help them get back on their feet. The fact it was also close to the city they worked in didn't hurt.

As a generous landlord, he shouldered all expenses but had one simple rule: no major renovations. On a visit a year ago, it seemed like only a bit of painting had been done. Fair enough.

Fast forward to the present, and the house started to strain OP’s finances. Additionally, it became a constant reminder of their mother's absence, which made it a burdensome emotional anchor. 

Offers from interested buyers were steadily pouring in, so the decision to sell seemed not only practical but necessary for OP’s mental well-being.

He broke the news to his daughter and gave her six months to find a new place—she didn’t take it too well. She revealed she and her husband had invested significantly in upgrades – redoing the stairs and the kitchen, and are currently midway through a bathroom renovation. 

She accused OP of unfairly benefiting from their improvements, but they did ring it loud that there were to be no major renovations. Was OP the AH in this situation?

Let’s dig into the details

OP inherited a house from her mother, but due to financial difficulties faced by her daughter and husband, she allowed them to stay in it.

The house OP inherited is eating into her finances and she decided to sell it.

OP informed her daughter of her decision and advised she should get a new place. This caused an argument between OP and her mother based on the fact that her daughter made some renovations to the house.

Check out some interesting comments below:

“Why even bother asking if you're the AH since you can't even consider different points of view?”

“Just because you can do something doesn’t mean you should or there is no other way.”

“Why didn't you just ask your daughter to start paying rent to cover whatever its costing you financially?”

“You do have the right to sell, especially if the home is becoming a financial burden to you.”

“To assume they could continue living there for free while also making unauthorized changes to the home was ballsy and entitled.”

“Legally you don’t need to reimburse them but ethically the right thing to do is to give them either what they spent, or the excess value realized when the house is sold.”

So, where does this leave OP? Torn between practicality and family loyalty, that’s where. Redditors believe the decision ultimately rests on how much value they place on helping their daughter versus their own well-being. 

It's clear: the house is theirs, and selling it is within their rights. But whether they should – that’s a question only they can answer, balancing love for their daughter against their own mental and financial health.

What do you think about this story? Let us know in the comments.

Jesse