Redditor Grapples With Picking The Perfect Steak For Office Christmas Party Without Sidelining The Medium Well & Well-Done Folks For Their "Cheap" Taste

"My pick is Wagyu, but I might have to buy lower grade stakes for the Medium Well & Well-Done folks."

Jesse

• Published in Interesting
• November 20, 2023

When it comes to planning an office Christmas party, there's a lot to consider – from decorations to entertainment and, of course, the menu. However, in the case of one Reddit user (OP), the culinary aspect of their holiday celebration is taking an unexpected twist.

OP, who has taken on the responsibility of procuring steaks for the event, has chosen to go above and beyond by opting for the luxurious choice of Wagyu steaks. It's a gourmet treat that promises unmatched flavor and tenderness.

Yet, their festive spirit has been dampened upon discovering that some of their colleagues prefer their steaks cooked to a well-done or medium-well level, where the distinct qualities of Wagyu might be lost in the process.

In an attempt to balance budget and preferences, OP is contemplating buying lower-grade steaks for those who enjoy their meat well-done or medium-well. Their rationale is that these less expensive cuts might fare better under such thorough cooking conditions while still offering a satisfying dining experience.

The question at the heart of this predicament is whether such a move would be seen as inconsiderate or, as OP puts it, make them "the a**hole" of the party. Is it acceptable to serve different grades of meat based on how guests prefer it cooked, or is there a more diplomatic solution to this culinary puzzle?

A lot of steak lovers in the house would definitely want to give their 2 cents on this matter. Scroll down to see how Netizens reacted to the story.

The story in detail

A bit of background

Important edits

We gathered the most interesting comments for your viewing pleasure:

“Maybe send an email? Let people know in advance, and explain that there will be 2 types of steak, wagyu and prime.”

“I think honesty is key here. So NTA.”

“You said you're being open about it/not lying to anyone. I think this is a smart and fair decision.”

“I feel like if something like this happened in just about any office I've worked in, and people found out, everyone would be kind of like, ‘..what the fuck?’…”

“If anyone complains, then they need to suck it up or pay for their own meal from somewhere else.“

“YTA, yeah. Let people eat how they want.”

“My advice, get the different cuts but ask people what cut they want AND how they want it cooked.”

“Don’t cheap out on those people because of their preferences, focus instead on cooking it properly.“

“YTA. I like my steak well done and I can 100% tell the difference.”

“YTA- I’d be really surprised if this didn’t create bad feelings from the well done folks.“

“NTA… I would tell them it’s a different cut with the right marbling for medium well or well done.”

In the spirited Reddit discussion, commenters found themselves divided on the matter. While some praised OP for their honesty in considering different steak cuts to cater to diverse preferences, others cautioned against potential pitfalls.

Some commenters expressed concern that serving cheaper cuts to those who prefer well-done steaks might lead to discomfort among some colleagues. Hopefully, OP can find a way to give their colleagues a party to remember.

We'd love to get your thoughts on the story. Join the conversation in the comments.

Jesse