AITA For Not Keeping Ibuprofen At Home

When personal habits clash, who bears the responsibility?

Davy

• Published in Interesting
• May 25, 2024

In a relationship spanning six months, a 24-year-old man found himself in an unexpected dilemma with his 29-year-old girlfriend. Frequently visiting each other’s homes and occasionally spending the night, they had fallen into a comfortable routine.

However, this harmony was disrupted when she woke up with severe period cramps during a sleepover. She asked him for Ibuprofen, and while he had two pills, they weren’t enough to alleviate her pain.

His preference for Thomapyrine for headaches meant he rarely kept Ibuprofen on hand, leading to her frustration. She argued that having Ibuprofen is a basic necessity, especially since she needs it frequently. He believed it was her responsibility to bring her own medication.

After reading about this couple's predicament, it's clear that their differing views on medication storage have caused a rift. He felt that his limited need for Ibuprofen didn’t justify keeping a stock at home, while she saw it as a basic courtesy given her frequent use.

The discussion has garnered mixed opinions. Here are some comments from others on this issue:

She should just keep a bottle in her purse. Most women keep something for headaches/cramps on them. She sounds irrational.

NTA for not having it then.

Absolutely! It’s the tiniest piece of effort for her comfort and it’s a nice gesture, what is the downside?

Why is everybody saying she was rude? OP only said she got upset.

ESH - you weren’t until the very end. You didnt have it, she didnt need to yell at you for that.

She shouldn’t have gotten upset you didn’t have ibuprofen right that moment.

In conclusion, navigating the expectations and responsibilities within a relationship can be tricky, especially when it comes to personal habits and needs. What would you do in this situation? Let us know in the comments!

Davy