Expectant Couple Get Into Heated Argument Because Boyfriend Insists On Naming Their Child After Deceased Sister If It's A Girl

Baby naming conflict

Jesse

• Published in Interesting
• April 20, 2023

Choosing a name for a baby can be one of the most exciting and challenging parts of preparing for a new arrival. Both mom and dad want the name to be perfect and a true reflection of the love they have for their child.

However, it can also be a contentious issue, especially when one partner wants to name the baby after a deceased family member. This is the predicament that one expectant mother finds herself in, and she's not sure whether she's in the wrong or not.

In this scenario, the mother-to-be is pregnant with her first child, and she and her partner have been discussing potential names. Choosing a baby name for a boy was easy, but her partner is keen on naming their baby after his deceased sister if it's a girl.

However, the mother-to-be doesn't feel comfortable with the idea, as she didn't have a close relationship with her partner's sister. In addition, she doesn't want their child to feel like they're just a memory of their aunt.

The situation has caused a rift between the couple, with the man accusing the expectant mom of being selfish and immature for not wanting to name their baby after his sister.

Meanwhile, his family is also pressuring the expectant mother to agree to the name. But is she really in the wrong?

Check out the full story below:

OP and her boyfriend are having a baby. But the problem is, her boyfriend is insisting on naming the baby after his late sister if it's a girl

OP and her sister-in-law never really got along. In addition, OP isn't happy about naming her child after a family member who just passed away

OP spoke to her boyfriend about how she feels. Now he's upset and sees OP as selfish

We gathered some reactions from the Reddit community:

"Compromise for the middle name is reasonable, and he's over-reacting."

"Both parents need to agree on the name or it’s out."

"I think both parents should come to a mutual agreement."

"

A personal story from one Redditor

"Stand firm. Use the name as a middle name. Don't let anyone beat you into giving your child a name you dislike."

"Absolutely do not do that. It's a horrible thing to do to a child, your baby will be there own person not a replacement for his sister."

"He has no respect for your feelings and reasonings, which frankly are all valid."

"You've offered to give your baby their daughter's name as a middle name. It's a good compromise."

"Using the loved ones name might seem like an honor but how long before it becomes unbearable?"

"He doesn't get to insist you name the baby after a person you basically tolerated."

"I think suggesting the middle name was an incredibly fair option."

Naming a baby after a deceased family member can be a beautiful way to honor their memory, but it's not a decision that should be made lightly. It's essential to consider the feelings of both parents and to choose a name that feels meaningful and significant to both of them.

In this case, the expectant mother has valid reasons for not wanting to name their baby after her partner's sister. While compromise may be possible, it's essential that both partners feel comfortable and happy with the chosen name.

Ultimately, the decision should be based on what's best for the baby rather than on pressure from others.

Jesse