Mom Refuses To Send Deceased Family Dog's Collar And Toy To Her Child Because She Is Afraid Their Partner Might Destroy It

Should she withhold a sentimental gift from her son's unstable partner?

Lakeisha

• Published in Interesting
• January 11, 2023

2474Volvo on Reddit recently shared a dilemma on the platform's "AITA" subreddit. In the post, she disclosed that she had to put her dog down last Friday and is devastated by the loss.

Her adult child (they, them), who now lives across the country and once shared the dog with her, requested the dog's collar and favorite toy as a Christmas gift. While she doesn't have a problem with giving them the items, 2474Volvo is hesitant because their partner has a history of destroying sentimental items during arguments.

Although they told her that the relationship had ended, 2474Volvo learned that this is not the case and the relationship is still ongoing. She is concerned that the collar and toy, which have sentimental value, could be destroyed by their partner if they become angry.

While she does not want to make them choose between her and their partner, she also does not want to risk losing sentimental items that cannot be replaced. She wonders if she will be seen as the "a-hole" if she does not send them the collar and toy.

Here's what the AITA community had to say on the topic:

Here's OP's story.

1. It's best that she keeps the items.

2. She should consider having a heart-to-heart conversation with her child.

3. She should discuss the situation with her child to arrive at a compromise.

4. She should do what she thinks is best for the items since they are also important to her.

5. Her concerns are valid.

6. She could keep them until the circumstances are right to hand them over to her child.

7. It's normal to be worried in this situation.

8. She has no business in helping to safeguard her child's sentimental objects.

9. She might have to wait until the relationship has truly ended.

What Do You Think?

Sentimental gifts can be some of the most meaningful and treasured possessions we own. They often hold significant emotional value and can be a source of comfort and joy.

They may be items that have been passed down through generations or gifts that were given to us by someone special. No matter their origin, sentimental gifts are often irreplaceable and can hold a great deal of value to the person who owns them.

Therefore, it is important to handle them with care and consideration. This may involve safeguarding them from potential damage or loss, as well as being mindful of who we share them with.

In some cases, it may be necessary to make difficult decisions about whether or not to give a sentimental gift to someone, especially if there is a risk that it could be damaged or lost due to their behavior.

Ultimately, the decision about whether or not to give a sentimental gift will depend on the specific circumstances and the priorities of the person considering the gift. It may be helpful to think about what is most important to us, as well as the potential risks and rewards of sharing a sentimental gift.

It may also be helpful to seek professional counseling to help us navigate these types of difficult decisions. What do you think?

Lakeisha