Sir Ian McKellen Shuts Down Any Talk Of Replacing Him As Gandalf With Epic Response

If he has his way, Gandalf will remain his role for as long as Middle-earth needs its wise and powerful wizard.

Sophia

• Published in Film & TV
• September 4, 2024

It’s nearly impossible to imagine anyone other than Sir Ian McKellen portraying the iconic wizard Gandalf in The Lord of the Rings. The 85-year-old actor, who has masterfully embodied the character across Peter Jackson's legendary trilogy and The Hobbit prequels, recently made it clear that he has no intention of passing on the wizard’s hat and staff anytime soon.

McKellen’s portrayal of Gandalf has become the gold standard, so much so that the thought of another actor stepping into those wizarding shoes seems almost unthinkable. His deep voice, commanding presence, and nuanced performance have forever linked him to the role.

McKellen himself agrees with this sentiment. When asked about the possibility of being replaced, he quipped during a BBC Breakfast interview, "I'm not letting anyone else put on the pointy hat and beard if I can help it."

This statement comes as excitement builds for The Hunt for Gollum, a Lord of the Rings prequel film set for release in 2026. While Andy Serkis is slated to reprise his role as Gollum and also direct the film, McKellen expressed his eagerness to return as Gandalf.

"Enthusiasm for The Lord of the Rings shows no sign of abating," McKellen said in a recent interview with The Big Issue. He hinted at future projects involving Gandalf, adding, "I’ve been told there are going to be more films, and Gandalf will be involved. They hope that I'll be playing him."

McKellen’s deep connection to Gandalf isn’t surprising.

Since his debut as the wise wizard in 2001, he has become synonymous with the character, earning worldwide acclaim and cementing his place in cinematic history. His portrayal of Gandalf in both The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit trilogies garnered him critical acclaim and helped solidify the films' place in the annals of film history.

McKellen’s commitment to the character is evident, as he continues to keep an eye on upcoming Lord of the Rings projects, including Prime Video’s prequel series The Rings of Power and the animated film The War of the Rohirrim, which is set to be released in December.

However, McKellen’s illustrious career hasn’t been without its challenges.

In June, while performing in Player Kings in London’s West End, he sustained injuries to his wrist and vertebrae after a fall from the stage. Reflecting on the incident, McKellen told BBC Radio 4’s Today program that while he is physically recovering, the emotional impact is something he’s still working through.

"I said to myself as I tripped and slid off the stage, 'This is the end.' And apparently, I shouted out, 'My neck is broken, I'm dying.' I don't remember saying that," he shared, highlighting the intense experience.

Despite these setbacks, McKellen’s determination to return as Gandalf remains unshaken. His passion for the role and dedication to his craft are qualities that have defined his illustrious career, which spans decades and includes a wide array of memorable performances.

Whether through his unforgettable portrayal of Gandalf or his unwavering commitment to theater, Sir Ian McKellen continues to captivate audiences worldwide. And if he has his way, Gandalf will remain in his role for as long as Middle-earth needs its wise and powerful wizard.

Sophia