Family Feud Over A Disneyland Trip - "Should I Have Offered To Pay For My Sister"

When family finances and holiday plans collide, emotions run high over who should foot the bill.

Davy

• Published in Interesting
• June 10, 2024

A recent post on Reddit's "Am I the A**hole" subreddit has ignited a discussion about family dynamics, financial responsibilities, and boundaries. The story comes from a woman who shared a conflict with her sister over a planned trip to Disneyland with her boyfriend.

The trip was meant to be a special outing to see the Christmas decorations, combining her love for Disney and the holiday season. Her sister, who still lives at home and struggles financially, asked if she could tag along and stay with them at their hotel, emphasizing her inability to afford such a trip on her own.

The poster’s response was blunt: she suggested that maybe her sister’s boyfriend, Tey, could pay for the trip. This comment was not well-received, as Tey is known for not contributing financially at home and bouncing from job to job.

The sister was hurt by the remark and went to their father in tears. While their father also dislikes Tey, he scolded the poster, warning her that her boyfriend might not always be around to support her.

This escalated further when their mother called, criticizing the poster for being insensitive and suggesting she ask her boyfriend to let the sister join their trip. The story delves into the complexities of familial expectations, financial dependence, and the boundaries of generosity.

It highlights the tensions that can arise when different family members have varying levels of financial stability and expectations about supporting each other. This article summarizes the original Reddit post, explores the reactions from the community, and invites readers to consider how they might handle similar situations.

Op starts : My boyfriend is taking me to Disneyland

He really doesn’t help out and bounces from job to job

This sent my sister in tears to my father

I left my parents home upset

My mom who was working at the time heard what had happened and called me a major b!+

I couldn’t afford to pay for her ticket

In her Reddit post, the woman explained that her boyfriend was taking her to Disneyland to see the Christmas decorations, a trip she was eagerly anticipating. Her sister, struggling financially and living at home, asked if she could join and stay with them at their hotel.

The poster, not fond of her sister's boyfriend Tey, suggested that maybe he could pay for the trip instead, knowing he rarely contributes financially.

This comment upset her sister, leading to a family confrontation where her father and mother criticized her for being insensitive. Despite her family's reaction, she stands by her belief that it’s not her boyfriend's responsibility to cover the costs for her sister.

NTA just because you and your boyfriend are acting like adults

Reddit

Your mom is certainly an AH

Reddit

NTA, she kept trying to guilt trip you and crash your vacation

Reddit

This story has sparked a debate about family responsibilities and financial boundaries. What do you think about the situation?

Should the poster have handled her sister's request differently? Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below, and let us know how you would navigate such a sensitive family issue.

Davy